All over America, one of the biggest arguments is weather the minimum
wage should be raised. Some people say that our current wage is not enough to
live on and it needs to be raised so that people can maintain a healthy life.
On the other side, people that are against raising the minimum wage argue that
a higher minimum wage would be too heavy a burden on employers. That means that
those employers would not be able to hire as many people. Therefore, there would
be no point to raising the wage at all. There are always two sides to every
story. Should the minimum wage be raised or should it remain the same?
The first side that we will discuss is raising minimum wage. As of now,
most people that are earning minimum wage are below the federal poverty level
of $15,130. By working forty hours a week at $7.25, they are only earning
$15,080 per year. However, about 70% of these minimum wage employees do not
even work forty hours a week. On average they work less then thirty-five hours
a week, therefore earning much less then the federal poverty level. Some
would even argue that an increase in the minimum wage would stimulate the
economy. If low-income households are earning more money per year, they would
be more likely to spend that money. This would put that money back into the
economy and everyone would benefit. The Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago
conducted an experiment where they found out that if the minimum wage were
increased, the average spending per household would increase by $2,800 per
year. "By increasing workers' take-home pay, families gain both
financial security and an increased ability to purchase goods and services,
thus creating jobs for other Americans" (Federal Reserve Bank of
Chicago). Overall, supporters of increasing the minimum wage would support that
a higher minimum wage would kick start the economy and benefit these hard
working individuals who can barely support their families.
On the opposing side, there are many people who are
against raising the minimum wage. They argue that that the employment rates
would go down due to employers not being able to pay enough employees such
a high wage. This would be especially bad for the small business owners who
would barely be able to support any employees at all. Jeff Jacoby, a supporter
of keeping the minimum wage where it is, argues, "When legislators
raise the price of low- and unskilled labor, it’s usually low- and unskilled
laborers who end up paying the price". They also argue that by increasing
the minimum wage, it does not mean that it will lower the poverty rate.
According to the Employment Policies Institute, "Multiple studies
have demonstrated little to no relationship between a higher minimum wage and
reductions in poverty". A lot of people who are against the increase also
agree that workers should be able to accept less then minimum wage. If a worker
is getting the job just for experience and it is not very time or labor
consuming they should be able to earn less then $7.25.
These two arguments are targeting
specifically the people right around the poverty line that are working minimum
wage jobs. One side argues that they are not making enough to support
their lives, while the other side argues that they do not need to make any more
for labor that does not require much skill. Both side look at each other
in a dismissive way, they both think that the other side is very wrong and do
not really agree on any points. Overall, people are all going to have
their own opinions. Will the minimum wage be raised, or will it stay
right where it is? Change is hard in a world where people struggle to
see opposing sides. In my opinion, no change will happen to the minimum
wage until people start to see the other side of the argument.
Sources:
http://www.forbes.com/sites/johntharvey/2015/07/31/real-argument-for-raising-minimum-wage/
http://www.salary.com/increasing-the-minimum-wage-pros-cons/
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/bill-quigley/top-ten-arguments-for-rai_b_6879220.html
You do a pretty good job here of summarizing the talking points used by people arguing for and against raising the minimum wage. This assignment was meant to give you the opportunity to compare two specific arguments for tactics and strategy. There are many relative merits to raising, or not, the minimum wage - but an overall evaluation is a matter of political opinion.
ReplyDeleteConsider how a group calling for a raise in the wage conducts their public campaign. Do they run ads? Do they do online outreach? Do they primarily speak to people who are currently in minimum wage jobs - or the unemployed - or folks in better-paying jobs? Is the appeal based on a broad call for "fairness"? Is "fairness" defined in a real way, or is that appeal more like an enthymeme? Now how about a specific effort to keep the wage where it is - ask the same basic questions.
Let me know how I can help.